Ultimate Guide to the Best Cocktails in St Thomas

When it comes to enjoying a tropical getaway, St. Thomas stands out as an idyllic destination filled with pristine beaches, vibrant culture, and remarkable culinary experiences. One of the most captivating aspects of any visit to this Caribbean paradise is the diverse range of cocktails available, each crafted with local ingredients and inspired by island flavors. Here, we’ve compiled a list of the 25 best cocktails in St. Thomas, showcasing not just the drink but also the ambiance that makes each selection unique. Let’s dive in!

Best Bars in St Thomas

St Thomas Travel Guide

1. Painkiller

Close-up view of a Painkiller cocktail with orange garnish — Painkiller is a tropical cocktail overflowing with flavors.

The Painkiller is a classic Caribbean cocktail that perfectly embodies the spirit of St. Thomas. Made with rum, coconut cream, orange juice, and pineapple juice, the Painkiller is a smooth, creamy drink that transports you to a sun-soaked beach with every sip.

Try it at one of the local beach bars while you enjoy the sound of tropical waves lapping against the shore.

2. Bushwacker

Eye-level view of a Bushwacker cocktail with chocolate shavings — Bushwacker features rich flavors and a creamy texture that tantalizes the taste buds.

Bushwackers are famous for their indulgent blend of rum, coffee liqueur, chocolate, and coconut cream. This decadent frozen cocktail is a true delight, appealing to those who enjoy dessert-like drinks.

Be sure to savor it at sunset, watching the sky turn into a canvas of colors as you sip on this sweet concoction.

3. Rum Punch

High angle view of a colorful Rum Punch cocktail with fruit garnishes — Vibrant Rum Punch cocktail showcasing tropical fruits garnishes.

A trip to St. Thomas isn’t complete without a refreshing Rum Punch. This cocktail combines rum with fruit juices, such as pineapple and orange, sometimes with a splash of grenadine for that gorgeous sunset hue.

Each bar in St. Thomas boasts its own twist on this beloved drink. Remember to try the variations to find your favorite!

4. Frozen Mojito

Close-up view of a Frozen Mojito cocktail covered with mint leaves — Refreshing Frozen Mojito cocktail featuring spearmint and lime.

The Frozen Mojito takes the classic Mojito to a new level by blending ice with the signature combination of rum, fresh mint, lime juice, and sugar. This icy refreshment is perfect for cooling down on a hot day.

Enjoy this cocktail at a local beachside café as you relish in the stunning views of the turquoise ocean.

5. Mango Daiquiri

Eye-level view of a Mango Daiquiri cocktail with a fresh mango slice — Delicious Mango Daiquiri garnished with a fresh mango slice.

The Mango Daiquiri is a fruity twist on the traditional Daiquiri, combining fresh mango purée with rum and lime juice. This tropical drink is not only beautiful but incredibly delicious.

Sip on a Mango Daiquiri while lounging by the pool, ensuring your perfect day continues to unfold.

6. Dark ’n’ Stormy

High angle view of a Dark ’n’ Stormy cocktail with lime wedge — Robust Dark ’n’ Stormy cocktail with a slice of lime.

Originating from Bermuda, the Dark ’n’ Stormy has become a sought-after drink across the Caribbean. This cocktail is made with dark rum and ginger beer, creating a stormy appearance and a robust flavor.

Pair this drink with spicy seafood dishes for a dining experience you’ll never forget.

7. Pina Colada

Close-up view of a Pina Colada cocktail topped with fresh pineapple — Classic Pina Colada garnished with fresh pineapple slice.

No tropical getaway is complete without the iconic Pina Colada. Blending rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice, this cocktail is synonymous with paradise.

Enjoy it at a beachfront bar, letting the flavors whisk you away to a sandy getaway.

8. Strawberry Basil Fizz

High angle view of a Strawberry Basil Fizz cocktail with basil leaves — Refined Strawberry Basil Fizz cocktail featuring fresh basil leaves.

The Strawberry Basil Fizz is a refreshing cocktail that combines muddled strawberries and fresh basil with gin and soda. This unique concoction is perfect for those looking for something a little different.

Relaxing on a patio while enjoying this cocktail will surely make your afternoon glamorous.

9. Mojito

Eye-level view of a classic Mojito cocktail with lime wedges — Classic Mojito cocktail featuring lime and fresh mint.

The traditional Mojito remains a favorite for its crisp and refreshing profile. Made with white rum, mint leaves, sugar, lime juice, and soda water, this cocktail is a go-to option for a reason.

Enjoy a Mojito at a lively bar, soaking in the atmosphere around you.

10. Coconut Margarita

Close-up view of a Coconut Margarita cocktail garnished with lime — Tropical Coconut Margarita cocktail with a lime garnish.

The Coconut Margarita adds a twist to the classic margarita with coconut cream blended into the mix. This delightful fusion of flavors truly captures the essence of island living.

Sip this drink as you watch the sunset for an unforgettable end to your day.

11. Spicy Margarita

High angle view of a Spicy Margarita cocktail with chili rim — Vibrant Spicy Margarita garnished with chili powder on the rim.

For those who love a kick, the Spicy Margarita is a fantastic option. Made with tequila, lime juice, and jalapeño, this cocktail is as bold as it is flavorful.

Enjoy it at a trendy bar in St. Thomas, paired with some zesty appetizers.

12. Strawberry Daiquiri

Close-up view of a Strawberry Daiquiri cocktail adorned with a strawberry — Strawberry Daiquiri cocktail with a fresh strawberry on the rim.

The Strawberry Daiquiri is a delightful frozen drink that combines strawberries, rum, and lime juice, resulting in a refreshing and photogenic cocktail.

This vibrant drink is perfect for a day at the beach or a fun evening outing.

13. Blue Lagoon

Eye-level view of a Blue Lagoon cocktail with lemon garnish — Bright Blue Lagoon cocktail adorned with a lemon slice.

The Blue Lagoon’s striking blue hue, thanks to Blue Curacao, gives it a visually stunning profile. Combined with vodka and lemonade, this cocktail is sure to turn heads.

Order it during a night out, and you’ll find yourself captivated by both its look and taste.

14. Piña Colada Float

High angle view of a Piña Colada Float cocktail with ice cream — Decadent Piña Colada Float topped with ice cream.

For an utterly indulgent experience, try a Piña Colada Float—an inventive take that features a scoop of coconut ice cream atop the classic drink. This dessert cocktail is a true tropical treat.

It’s a fun addition to any beach picnic or poolside gathering.

15. Coral Reef

Close-up view of a Coral Reef cocktail with orange peel — Vibrant Coral Reef cocktail showcasing an orange peel garnish.

Named for the beautiful underwater life surrounding the islands, the Coral Reef combines rum, orange juice, and a splash of cranberry juice. Its vibrant colors make it a perfect Instagram-worthy drink.

Enjoy this cocktail as you take in the stunning ocean views.

16. Tropical Sangria

High angle view of a Tropical Sangria cocktail with fruits — Colorful Tropical Sangria filled with sliced fruits.

Infused with tropical flavors, Tropical Sangria is a blend of red or white wine mixed with fresh fruits and citrus. This refreshing drink is ideal for sharing with friends at your favorite bar.

Make it a refreshing addition to your next group outing.

17. Local Beer Mojito

Close-up view of a Local Beer Mojito cocktail with beer can — Unique Local Beer Mojito with a splash of local beer.

Combining local beer with classic Mojito ingredients leads to the innovative Local Beer Mojito! It’s a perfect balance of refreshing and robust flavors.

You can discover this unique drink at a local pub or bar that takes pride in craft cocktails.

18. Lemon Drop Martini

Eye-level view of a Lemon Drop Martini cocktail with sugar rim — Zesty Lemon Drop Martini cocktail with a sugar rim.

Bright and zesty, the Lemon Drop Martini is a refreshing cocktail made with vodka, lemon juice, and a touch of sweetness from sugar. Perfect for a night out, it adds a sparkle to any occasion.

Indulge in this delightful drink while embracing St. Thomas’s vibrant nightlife.

19. Electric Smurf

High angle view of an Electric Smurf cocktail with blue hue — Striking Electric Smurf cocktail capturing tropical tones.

The Electric Smurf cocktail is a playful mix that features various blue liqueurs and rum. It’s colorful, fun, and perfect for a spirited night out.

Experience the electric atmosphere of St. Thomas nightlife as you sip this exciting drink.

20. Guava Mimosa

Close-up view of a Guava Mimosa cocktail garnished with fruit — Exotic Guava Mimosa cocktail featuring a fruit garnish.

The Guava Mimosa takes brunch to a whole new level with its fruity twist on the classic Mimosa. Made with guava juice and champagne, this cocktail is a delightful way to start your day.

Enjoy this elegant drink at a seaside café while indulging in a delicious brunch.

21. Raspberry Mint Julep

High angle view of a Raspberry Mint Julep cocktail with mint leaves — Refreshing Raspberry Mint Julep cocktail sprinkled with mint.

The refreshing Raspberry Mint Julep is a unique take on the traditional Julep, made with fresh raspberries, mint, and bourbon. This cocktail is not only refreshing but also a delightful visual treat.

Sip this drink at a relaxed outdoor bar as you embrace the island vibes.

22. Cherry Limeade

Close-up view of a Cherry Limeade cocktail with cherry garnish — Vibrant Cherry Limeade cocktail topped with a cherry.

Cherry Limeade is a fruity refresher that combines cherry juice, lime juice, and soda for a bubbly drink bursting with flavor. This delightful beverage is a perfect choice on a hot day.

Make sure to enjoy it under the sun, perhaps after a dip in the water.

23. Tropical Bellini

Eye-level view of a Tropical Bellini cocktail with a peach slice — Delightful Tropical Bellini cocktail adorned with a peach slice.

The Tropical Bellini captures the essence of summer with its mix of peach and tropical fruit purees, topped with sparkling wine. This light, bubbly cocktail is perfect for festive occasions.

Raise a glass filled with this cheerful drink at your next celebration!

24. Green Flash

High angle view of a Green Flash cocktail with lime wedge — Vibrant Green Flash cocktail showcasing its unique shade.

The Green Flash cocktail is a visually stunning drink that combines vodka, melon liqueur, and pineapple juice for a refreshing taste. Its vibrant green color adds to its allure.

Enjoy it during happy hour at a scenic spot, making for a delightful sunset toast.

25. Island Breeze

Close-up view of an Island Breeze cocktail with citrus garnish — Colorful Island Breeze cocktail standard garnished with citrus.

The Island Breeze cocktail features a delightful combination of cranberry juice, pineapple juice, and vodka. Its fruity flavors and bright colors encapsulate the essence of the islands.

This drink is an excellent companion for a beach day, providing the perfect midsummer escape.

Conclusion

St. Thomas is undoubtedly a melting pot of flavors, and its cocktail offerings are a testament to the vibrant culture that thrives on the island. Whether you prefer fruity, creamy, or adventurous flavors, you’ll be able to find a refreshing drink that perfectly complements your surroundings.

As you explore the stunning beaches and indulge in the local cuisine, make sure to explore these 25 best cocktails in St. Thomas. Each sip offers a taste of paradise, inviting you to unwind and soak up the beauty of this Caribbean jewel. Cheers to your next island adventure!

KW Adventure Explorer