Ultimate Guide to the Best Fishing in St John

Fishing in St. John goes beyond just casting a line. It is a delightful way to immerse yourself in nature, enjoy the stunning surroundings, and engage with the rich sea life of the Caribbean. With its blend of tranquil settings and vibrant marine ecosystems, St. John offers a treasure trove of fishing spots ideal for both novice anglers and seasoned pros. In this blog post, we’ll dive into the 25 best fishing spots in St. John, highlighting what makes each location special and what you can expect to catch.

Travel Guide: St John

1. Trunk Bay

Scenic view of Trunk Bay, St John, with calm blue waters — Tranquil waters of Trunk Bay perfect for fishing

Trunk Bay is renowned as one of the most beautiful beaches globally, with its stunning clear waters and vibrant marine life. This spot is well-suited for beginners due to gentle currents. Anglers here can typically catch snapper and grouper while enjoying the incredible underwater scenery.

2. Cinnamon Bay

Aerial view of Cinnamon Bay surrounded by lush greenery — A scenic overview of Cinnamon Bay’s inviting shores

Cinnamon Bay presents excellent fishing possibilities. The shallow waters close to the shore are prime for catching species like mackerel and barracuda. It’s also a great place for snorkeling, allowing you to observe colorful fish while taking a break from fishing.

3. Maho Bay

Close-up view of the calm waters of Maho Bay — Calm waters of Maho Bay ideal for fishing activities

Maho Bay is famous for its serenity and stunning sunsets. The bay’s sheltered waters make it perfect for fishing. Here, you can expect to catch yellowtail snapper near the rocky edges, providing an enjoyable fishing experience while you soak in the views.

4. Louisenhoj

Wide angle view of Louisenhoj's rocky coastline — Rugged beauty of Louisenhoj’s coastline, a great fishing location

Located on the north coast, Louisenhoj has a rugged coastline with dramatic cliffs ideal for fishing. The area is known for a diverse array of fish species, including tarpon and jack crevalle. Anglers can find an exciting challenge here, often resulting in larger catches.

5. Salt Pond Bay

Eye-level view of a tranquil Salt Pond Bay — Serene atmosphere at Salt Pond Bay, perfect for quiet fishing

Salt Pond Bay is a local favorite, cherished for its peaceful waters. This hidden gem allows for solitude while fishing, making it an ideal setting for targeting different species, including triggerfish and parrotfish.

6. Fish Bay

High angle view of Fish Bay showcasing its clear waters — Beautiful waters of Fish Bay, an excellent fishing area

Fish Bay stands out for boat fishing, providing access to deeper waters where larger species swim. This less crowded bay is known for its ample fish activity. Anglers can expect to reel in tarpon and bonefish, enhancing their fishing experience.

7. Coral Bay

Wide view of Coral Bay with surrounding hills — Scenic Coral Bay offers ample fishing spots for enthusiasts

Coral Bay is vibrant, with a harbor that sees many boats. The surrounding mangroves serve as nurseries for smaller fish. Anglers here can catch various species, including snapper, but should remain aware of changing currents.

8. Bordeaux Mountain

High angle view of Bordeaux Mountain overlooking the ocean — Stunning viewpoint from Bordeaux Mountain, a strategic fishing location

Bordeaux Mountain isn’t just about hiking; it offers unique fishing spots along the shoreline. After a short trek, you can find great fishing opportunities and enjoy panoramic views of the island’s lush landscape.

9. Francis Bay

Sweeping view of Francis Bay with its gentle waves — Tranquil Francis Bay promising a peaceful fishing experience

Francis Bay is perfect for fly fishing due to its sandy bottom and clear waters. You can expect to catch diverse fish, including bonefish and permit. This spot combines relaxing fishing with the beauty of its natural surroundings.

10. Jumbie Bay

Clear waters of Jumbie Bay perfect for fishing enthusiasts — Jumbie Bay’s inviting waters are ideal for fishing

Jumbie Bay is an off-the-beaten-path location, making it ideal for peaceful fishing. Its secluded pristineness is perfect for catching smaller reef fish while enjoying the surrounding beauty.

11. Round Bay

Wide angle view of Round Bay with surrounding cliffs — Round Bay with its scenic cliffs provides a unique fishing experience

Round Bay features dramatic cliffs and bountiful marine life. Anglers can find rich fishing here, with various species congregating near rocky outcrops. Expect larger catches while casting along the cliffs.

12. Lameshur Bay

Eye-level view of the quiet waters of Lameshur Bay — Lameshur Bay, known for its tranquil waters and great fishing opportunities

Known for its tranquility, Lameshur Bay offers fantastic fishing settings where snapper and grouper are prominent catches. The quieter waters attract fewer anglers, making it a hidden treasure.

13. East End Beaches

High view of East End Beaches showcasing the vibrant colors — Vibrant East End Beaches, inviting for fishing and leisure

The East End Beaches comprise beautiful locations ideal for diverse fishing experiences. With numerous coral reefs, you can find various fish species here. Anglers often catch larger fish, making it a thrilling place to fish.

14. Brown Bay

Close-up view of Brown Bay with its serene waters — Brown Bay, a peaceful hideaway for fishing enthusiasts

Brown Bay offers a serene escape for fishing enthusiasts. Its calmer waters make it suitable for various fishing methods, including shore fishing. This secluded spot allows you to have a quiet day surrounded by nature.

15. Great Lameshur

Wide view of the tranquil waters of Great Lameshur — Great Lameshur’s serene waters are perfect for a day of fishing

Great Lameshur features deeper waters, making it excellent for catching larger fish. Enjoy the beautiful backdrop as you cast your line and wait for those bigger bites.

16. Turtle Bay

Calm waters of Turtle Bay promising plenty of fishing fun — Turtle Bay, an inviting area for fishing under the Caribbean sun

Turtle Bay is celebrated for its diverse wildlife. Families will enjoy fishing here, where the mix of sport and fun creates an engaging experience. Kids can learn about local fish species while enjoying a day out.

17. Waterlemon Cay

Scenic view of Waterlemon Cay surrounded by clear waters — Waterlemon Cay, a stunning spot for fishing and exploration

Accessed via a short hike, Waterlemon Cay serves as a unique fishing spot. The rich waters teem with fish, making it an excellent location for anglers wanting to enjoy both adventure and fishing.

18. Hawksnest Beach

Scenic beach view of Hawksnest Beach, perfect for fishing — Hawksnest Beach, a serene spot for both relaxation and fishing

Hawksnest Beach is favored by local fishermen for good reason. It boasts productive waters for different fish species, including snapper and tarpon. As you fish, you can take in the beauty of this picturesque location.

19. Salt Pond

Eye-level view of the serene Salt Pond, an excellent fishing destination — Quiet Salt Pond providing an ideal environment for fishing

Salt Pond offers a unique aquatic ecosystem. The crystal-clear waters enhance visibility, making it an exceptional place to learn about marine life while fishing. You’ll encounter a range of colorful fish species in this tranquil setting.

20. Johns Folly

Wide angle view of Johns Folly showcasing its untouched beauty — Johns Folly, an untouched paradise perfect for fishing

Johns Folly is an idyllic location for adventurous anglers. Its remote location means fewer people, allowing for a more immersive fishing experience. You can catch local fish while surrounded by stunning natural beauty.

21. Caneel Bay

High angle view of Caneel Bay, renowned for its beauty and fishing spots — Caneel Bay, a beautiful fishing location with diverse opportunities

Caneel Bay presents numerous fishing opportunities due to its varying depths. The surrounding scenery is breathtaking, and anglers here commonly catch tarpon and snapper, making it a popular location among fishing enthusiasts.

22. Peter Bay

Scenic view of Peter Bay with its clear waters and lush surroundings — Peter Bay, a picturesque location for fishing enthusiasts

Peter Bay is increasingly popular for fishing, thanks to its calm waters. Anglers can enjoy a variety of catches while relaxing in this beautiful, sun-soaked environment.

23. Caribbean Sea

Wide angle view of the Caribbean Sea with a perfect sky — Majestic view of the Caribbean Sea, offering vast fishing opportunities

The Caribbean Sea surrounding St. John presents a diverse fishing playground. Whether you prefer snorkeling or venturing into deep-sea fishing, the sea is abundant with life and endless adventure.

24. Virgin Islands National Park

Aerial view of Virgin Islands National Park showcasing diverse marine life — Virgin Islands National Park, a paradise for nature and fishing enthusiasts

Fishing in the Virgin Islands National Park is a memorable experience. The rich marine life provides fantastic opportunities for catches while being surrounded by stunning landscapes and relaxing natural beauty.

25. Hurricane Hole

High view of Hurricane Hole with its charming waters — Hurricane Hole, an enchanting place for fishing adventures

Hurricane Hole features captivating natural beauty alongside exceptional fishing. The calm, protected waters house a variety of fish species, making it a beloved spot for both casual and experienced anglers.

Wrapping Up the Adventure

St. John is truly a fishing paradise, offering a wide array of stunning spots, each with its own unique charm. Whether you are an avid angler or just looking to enjoy a serene day by the water’s edge, the fishing spots highlighted in this post provide something for everyone. With breathtaking views and peaceful waters, fishing in St. John is not just about the catches; it’s also a chance to appreciate the natural beauty of this Caribbean gem. Bring your fishing gear and get ready to dive into an adventure that awaits at these spectacular locales. Happy fishing!

KW Adventure Explorer