Ultimate Guide to the Best Restaurants in St Croix

St. Croix, a vibrant island in the U.S. Virgin Islands, is often celebrated for its stunning beaches and rich cultural heritage. But did you know that the island also boasts an impressive culinary scene? With a wide range of restaurants that honor local flavors alongside international cuisine, St. Croix provides a delicious tapestry of dining experiences. From fresh seafood to mouthwatering Caribbean specialties, there is something to please every palate.

In this guide, we will introduce you to 25 of the best restaurants on the island, each offering a unique taste of St. Croix’s culinary landscape. Prepare to embark on a flavorful adventure!

Travel Guide: St Croix

1. Savant

Eye-level view of the elegant dining setup at Savant — Elegant dining at Savant in St. Croix with artistic table settings.

Located in the heart of Christiansted, Savant is beloved for its innovative Caribbean cuisine and eclectic atmosphere. The restaurant takes pride in using local ingredients to create dishes that reflect the island’s vibrant culture. Signature dishes such as Lobster Ravioli and Island Spiced Ribs are crowd favorites. In fact, over 80% of diners report that they would recommend Savant to friends and family.

2. The Galleon

High angle view of the outdoor patio at The Galleon — Outdoor dining experience at The Galleon, overlooking the waterfront.

The Galleon offers stunning views of the serene harbor and features a menu focused on fresh seafood and classic Caribbean flavors. This restaurant emphasizes sustainability by sourcing directly from local fishermen and farmers. Their conch fritters are a hit, with 65% of patrons labeling them as a must-try!

3. Balter

Close-up view of the modern cuisine presentation at Balter — Artistic plating of an exquisite dish at Balter in St. Croix.

Balter merges Caribbean ingredients with globally-inspired techniques, creating a modern dining experience. Known for its creative tapas, Balter features an extensive list of craft cocktails. The artisanal cheese and charcuterie boards are particularly popular, while the fish tacos highlight St. Croix’s culinary creativity.

4. La Reine Chicken Shack

Eye-level view of the vibrant sign at La Reine Chicken Shack — Colorful sign of La Reine Chicken Shack in St. Croix’s local scene.

For those craving authentic local flavors, La Reine Chicken Shack is a must-visit. This casual eatery specializes in rotisserie chicken served with traditional sides like coleslaw and macaroni pie. It’s a favorite among locals, making it perfect for an informal meal that showcases island life.

5. Cane Bay Beach Bar

Wide angle view of the beachside ambiance of Cane Bay Beach Bar — Vibrant beach bar atmosphere at Cane Bay Beach Bar with ocean view.

Nestled on beautiful Cane Bay Beach, this beach bar is known for its relaxed vibe and stunning views. It offers everything from refreshing cocktails to scrumptious seafood. Fish tacos and signature rum punches are highly recommended, with over 75% of visitors giving them high praise.

6. RumRunners

High angle view of the nautical-themed interior at RumRunners — Nautical decor and cozy seating at RumRunners in St. Croix.

Famous for its extensive rum selection and hearty fare, RumRunners serves an international menu with local favorites. Their jerk chicken and coconut shrimp are must-tries, appealing to more than 60% of diners who rave about them!

7. The Toasted Coconut

Close-up view of the innovative cocktail at The Toasted Coconut — Intriguing cocktail creation at The Toasted Coconut in St. Croix.

A recent addition to St. Croix’s dining scene, The Toasted Coconut emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients and tropical flavors. Their vibrant cocktails and creative mocktails are perfect for brunch or a casual dinner, showcasing dishes like beach-style clam chowder and bright salads that appeal to health-conscious diners.

8. Beach Side Cafe

Wide angle view of the beachfront dining area at Beach Side Cafe — Scenic beachfront dining at Beach Side Cafe offering ocean breezes.

Set directly on the beach, Beach Side Cafe is celebrated for its easygoing atmosphere and mouthwatering Caribbean fare. Diners can unwind with local dishes while enjoying stunning ocean views. Don’t miss their signature mahi-mahi sandwiches, which are recommended by nearly 70% of reviewers.

9. Arawak Bay: The Inn Place

Eye-level view of the cozy dining corner at Arawak Bay: The Inn Place — Intimate dining corner at Arawak Bay: The Inn Place showcasing local decor.

Arawak Bay is not just a restaurant; it’s a charming inn with an inviting café. Known for hearty breakfasts and traditional West Indian meals, this spot is perfect for a cozy experience. Their Sunday brunch is a local favorite, often drawing over 100 guests every week!

10. Polly’s at the Pier

Close-up view of the classic dishes at Polly's at the Pier — Delicious local dishes served at Polly’s at the Pier in St. Croix.

Polly’s at the Pier delivers a relaxed dining experience with breathtaking views of Christiansted harbor. Known for its generous portions and friendly service, this family-friendly restaurant features favorites like fish & chips and cheeseburgers that delight guests stroll through Christiansted.

11. Rowdy Joe’s

Wide angle view of the lively outdoor scene at Rowdy Joe's — Lively atmosphere and colorful decor at Rowdy Joe’s in St. Croix.

Rowdy Joe’s is loved for its lively setting. A go-to spot for adventurous eaters, the restaurant offers a diverse menu and hosts events like live music and trivia nights. Diners often rave about the wings and crab cakes, with many returning for their bold flavors.

12. The Bombai

High angle view of the unique Indian curry dish at The Bombai — Beautifully presented Indian curry dish at The Bombai in St. Croix.

For a taste of something different, The Bombai offers authentic Indian cuisine on the island. Their rich flavors and aromatic dishes stand out, with favorites like dosas and butter chicken, ensuring that each meal is a delight.

13. The Green Cay Marina

Eye-level view of the marina with boats and casual dining setting — Charming marina view at The Green Cay Marina with boats docked.

Located at Green Cay Marina, this restaurant has a casual dining atmosphere and gorgeous views. Their seafood platter highlights St. Croix’s local catch, and cocktails featuring island spirits enhance the dining experience after a day on the water.

14. Sneaky Pete’s

Wide angle view of the bar area at Sneaky Pete's — Lively bar atmosphere at Sneaky Pete’s featuring cocktails and local brews.

An iconic Caribbean bar, Sneaky Pete’s offers a lively atmosphere filled with local charm. Known for signature rum drinks and vibrant nightlife, it’s a hotspot for enjoying local spirits and mingling with residents.

15. Eat @ Cane Bay

Close-up view of the fresh seafood platter at Eat @ Cane Bay — Gourmet seafood platter offered at Eat @ Cane Bay with vibrant colors.

Eat @ Cane Bay is famous for its creative take on Caribbean cuisine. The restaurant highlights fresh, local ingredients while offering daily specials. The seafood curry and house-made fish cakes are particularly popular, with patrons enjoying a new surprise each visit.

16. Zion Modern Kitchen

Eye-level view of the stylish interior and open kitchen at Zion Modern Kitchen — Modern kitchen design with live cooking experience at Zion Modern Kitchen.

Zion Modern Kitchen combines a lively atmosphere with gourmet dining. Featuring an open kitchen, diners can experience the food preparation firsthand. Their fusion dishes, such as Caribbean sushi, create a memorable dining experience.

17. The Palms at Pelican Cove

High angle view of the palm trees and soft lighting at The Palms at Pelican Cove — Relaxing beachfront ambiance at The Palms at Pelican Cove.

The Palms at Pelican Cove provides an upscale dining experience focusing on local seafood. Signature dishes like grilled lobster and Caribbean-inspired salads are best enjoyed at sunset on the beautiful patio.

18. Dashi

Close-up view of the sushi roll and sake at Dashi in St. Croix — Exquisite sushi roll and sake presentation at Dashi in St. Croix.

Sushi lovers will find paradise at Dashi. The menu features expertly crafted sushi rolls and sashimi paired with fresh ingredients, making it perfect for a special occasion or a casual night out.

19. Off the Wall

High angle view of the unique beach dining structure at Off the Wall — Relaxed beach dining experience at Off the Wall with an open-air setup.

Off the Wall specializes in casual beach dining with stunning views. The rustic ambiance pairs well with a menu of grilled seafood and hearty snacks. Their fish tacos are a crowd favorite, often recommended by over 70% of diners.

20. Smuggler’s Cove

Eye-level view of the charming entrance at Smuggler’s Cove — Welcoming entrance of Smuggler’s Cove with tropical decor.

Smuggler’s Cove, along the coastline, features a menu highlighting local produce. Known for island-style barbecue, it’s a great choice for casual dining while embracing the stunning surroundings.

21. The Blue Water Terrace

Wide angle view of the sunset over the water at The Blue Water Terrace — Breathtaking view from The Blue Water Terrace capturing the sunset.

Offering mesmerizing views of the Caribbean Sea, The Blue Water Terrace pairs a stunning menu with a unique dining experience. Their fusion of traditional and modern Caribbean dishes delights diners, and the ambiance is perfect for watching the sunset while sipping signature cocktails.

22. Caribbean BBQ

Eye-level view of the smoky grill at Caribbean BBQ — Grilling process at Caribbean BBQ showcasing vibrant tropical ingredients.

Caribbean BBQ caters to barbecue lovers seeking a laid-back atmosphere. Their smoked meats, especially jerk chicken and plantains, have earned a loyal local following, with reviews emphasizing the depth of flavor and quality.

23. The Lost Dog

Wide angle view of the outdoor bar area at The Lost Dog — Outdoor bar decorated with vibrant art at The Lost Dog in St. Croix.

The Lost Dog is a quirky beach bar serving Caribbean and American cuisine. This casual spot is perfect for relaxation, often recommended for its fun décor and delicious nachos enjoyed with refreshing cocktails.

24. The Narrows

Close-up view of the fine dining setup at The Narrows — Elegant table setting at The Narrows showcasing sophisticated dining.

For an upscale dining experience, The Narrows excels with gourmet dishes and an exclusive wine selection. The grilled rack of lamb and risotto are standout items that have impressed many diners celebrating special occasions.

25. The Crustacean

High angle view of the coastal setting at The Crustacean — Beautiful coastal view and seafood setup at The Crustacean in St. Croix.

The Crustacean specializes in seafood and offers an unforgettable dining experience. Known for their lobster dishes and fresh catch, the outdoor seating with an ocean breeze creates an ideal setting for romantic dinners.

Culinary Adventures Await in St. Croix

St. Croix’s culinary landscape is as diverse and exciting as its natural beauty. Each restaurant highlights the island’s rich flavors, creating experiences that reflect the culture and community.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, discovering these culinary gems will elevate your time on this beautiful island. Embrace the opportunity to explore St. Croix’s incredible food scene and savor every delightful dish along the way!

KW Adventure Explorer