Ultimate Guide to the Best Cocktails in St Croix

St. Croix, the largest of the U.S. Virgin Islands, offers more than just stunning beaches and rich history. It boasts an exciting cocktail scene that showcases the island’s vibrant culture and fresh, local ingredients. Each drink tells a story, reflecting the essence of island life. Join us as we explore 25 exquisite cocktails you simply must experience while visiting St. Croix.

Travel Guide: St Croix

1. Painkiller

Close-up view of a vibrant Painkiller cocktail with garnishes — A refreshing Painkiller cocktail, garnished with a sprinkle of nutmeg and a slice of orange.

The Painkiller is a must-try Caribbean classic made with a mix of rum, coconut cream, pineapple juice, and orange juice. Served over ice, this drink encapsulates tropical bliss. Its origins are rooted in the British Virgin Islands, but it has found a welcoming home on St. Croix. A sprinkle of nutmeg adds an aromatic twist, making each sip an escape.

2. Cruzan Hurricane

High angle view of a Cruzan Hurricane cocktail adorned with a cherry — A colorful Cruzan Hurricane cocktail, showcasing a blend of tropical flavors and garnished with fruit.

Celebrate rum culture with the Cruzan Hurricane. This vibrant cocktail combines light and dark Cruzan rum, passion fruit juice, fresh lime juice, and grenadine. Served over ice, it mirrors the bold intensity of a Caribbean summer storm, with about 20% alcohol content that promises a delightful kick.

3. Blackbeard’s Revenge

Eye-level view of a Blackbeard’s Revenge cocktail with dark rum — A dark and enticing Blackbeard’s Revenge cocktail, featuring a mix of rum and tropical juices.

Named after the infamous pirate, Blackbeard’s Revenge is a powerful mix of dark rum, coconut rum, and assorted fruit juices. This drink, often served in a chilled glass, is particularly popular among cocktail enthusiasts for its rich, alluring flavor and robust 35% alcohol content.

4. Mango Mojito

Close-up view of a refreshing Mango Mojito with mint leaves — A refreshing Mango Mojito cocktail, highlighting the vibrant colors of fresh mango and mint.

The Mango Mojito puts a tropical spin on the traditional Mojito, featuring fresh mango puree, mint, lime, and soda water. This sweet and refreshing cocktail is a favorite among locals, especially during the hot summer months when temperatures reach 90°F or higher.

5. Rum Punch

High angle view of a colorful Rum Punch cocktail surrounded by tropical fruits — A vibrant Rum Punch cocktail, showcasing an array of tropical fruits as garnishes.

Rum Punch is often referred to as a “party in a glass.” This delightful cocktail mixes Caribbean rums, fresh fruit juices, and a hint of spice to create a drink that delights the senses. Whether at a beach party or a family gathering, its bold flavors and eye-catching colors make it a must-have while in St. Croix.

6. Pina Colada

Eye-level view of a classic Pina Colada with pineapple garnish — A classic Pina Colada cocktail served in a coconut, garnished with a slice of pineapple.

No Caribbean getaway would be complete without a Pina Colada. This iconic cocktail mixes rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice until smooth. It’s often enjoyed while lounging on the sand, embodying the spirit of relaxation that St. Croix is known for. With an alcohol content around 15%, it’s the perfect afternoon treat.

7. Cucumber Cooler

Close-up view of a Cucumber Cooler cocktail adorned with cucumber slices — A refreshing Cucumber Cooler cocktail featuring slices of cucumber for garnish.

If you’re looking for something light, the Cucumber Cooler is an excellent choice. This refreshing drink combines gin, fresh cucumber, lime, and tonic water. Perfect for a sunny day, this cocktail is a crowd-pleaser with its clean flavors and crisp finish.

8. Dark and Stormy

High angle view of a Dark and Stormy cocktail with ginger beer bubbles — A frothy Dark and Stormy cocktail with dark rum and ginger beer, showcasing its layers.

The Dark and Stormy cocktail is a simple yet delightful mix of dark rum and ginger beer. Its kick comes from the spicy ginger complementing the smooth rum, making it a favorite choice for those who enjoy a full-bodied drink, especially during cooler island evenings.

9. Strawberry Daiquiri

Eye-level view of a Strawberry Daiquiri with fresh strawberries — A bright Strawberry Daiquiri cocktail garnished with fresh strawberries and mint leaves.

The Strawberry Daiquiri is a sweet and refreshing way to cool down on a hot day. Made with fresh strawberries, rum, and lime juice, this cocktail is often blended to create a delicious slush. Many enjoy it while watching the sunset, especially as temperatures drop to the pleasant 80s in the evenings.

10. Virgin Islands Mule

Close-up view of a Virgin Islands Mule cocktail with a lime wedge — A refreshing Virgin Islands Mule cocktail served in a copper mug with a slice of lime.

The Virgin Islands Mule offers a unique twist on the classic Moscow Mule by using Caribbean rum instead of vodka. Mixed with ginger beer and fresh lime, this cocktail is refreshing and zesty, making it a popular choice among visitors looking to explore St. Croix’s flavor profiles.

11. Blue Lagoon

High angle view of a Blue Lagoon cocktail with a tropical backdrop — A vibrant Blue Lagoon cocktail showcasing its striking blue color.

The Blue Lagoon stands out with its distinct blue color and refreshing taste. Made with blue curaçao, vodka, and lemonade, this drink is garnished with a slice of lemon for a pop of flavor. It’s visually dynamic, making it a hit on social media as well as in hand.

12. Tropical Tequila Sunrise

Eye-level view of a Tropical Tequila Sunrise cocktail layered with citrus — A vibrant Tropical Tequila Sunrise cocktail, featuring layered flavors of orange and grenadine.

A twist on the classic Tequila Sunrise, this tropical version adds a splash of fresh fruit juices for flavor. Blending tequila, orange juice, and grenadine creates a colorful drink that captures the essence of St. Croix’s stunning sunsets.

13. Mai Tai

Close-up view of a Mai Tai cocktail with colorful garnishes — A well-crafted Mai Tai cocktail, featuring an intricate mix of rum and fruity juices.

The Mai Tai is a timeless tropical cocktail made with aged rum, lime juice, orgeat syrup, and orange liqueur. Its complex flavors make it ideal for sipping while enjoying the sunset, embodying the laid-back island lifestyle.

14. Mango Margarita

High angle view of a Mango Margarita with a salted rim — A refreshing Mango Margarita cocktail served with a salted rim and garnished with lime.

Elevating the classic margarita, the Mango Margarita mixes tequila with fresh mango puree. The combination of citrus and sweetness pairs well with local cuisine, making it a must-try while in St. Croix.

15. Fishers’ Rum Garden Punch

Eye-level view of a Fishers’ Rum Garden Punch cocktail in a tropical setting — A delightful Fishers’ Rum Garden Punch cocktail featuring a garden-like presentation.

The Fishers’ Rum Garden Punch is a unique blend of local rums, various fruit juices, and a hint of mint. This refreshing concoction celebrates the island’s natural flavors and is a favorite among locals for its refreshing qualities.

16. Tropical Sangria

Close-up view of a Tropical Sangria with fresh fruits — A colorful Tropical Sangria cocktail filled with an abundance of fresh fruit slices.

Sangria is given a tropical twist in St. Croix. Combining white or red wine, rum, and a variety of fresh fruits like pineapples and mangoes, this drink is excellent for sharing with friends during a sunset gathering.

17. Coconut Mojito

High angle view of a Coconut Mojito served with a straw — A Coconut Mojito cocktail highlighting its refreshing coconut flavor and mint garnish.

The Coconut Mojito blends coconut water or cream with the classic ingredients of lime and mint. The creamy texture adds a new twist, enhancing the refreshing qualities of this St. Croix favorite.

18. Tropical Collins

Eye-level view of a Tropical Collins cocktail with citrus garnishes — A refreshing Tropical Collins cocktail highlighting its vibrant color and fruit garnishes.

This is a tropical reimagining of the classic Tom Collins, featuring gin and an assortment of fresh fruit juices. The effervescence from the soda adds a refreshing and sweet dimension perfect for leisurely afternoons.

19. Stormy Weather

High angle view of a Stormy Weather cocktail in a chilled glass — A smooth Stormy Weather cocktail with sophisticated layers of flavor.

The Stormy Weather cocktail combines dark rum, ginger beer, and a hint of spices for a cozy drink. It’s the perfect choice for an evening where comfort meets adventure.

20. Poison Berry

Eye-level view of a Poison Berry cocktail garnished with fresh berries — A colorful Poison Berry cocktail featuring a delightful mix of berry flavors.

The Poison Berry is a visually stunning drink that combines fresh berries with vodka or gin, topped with soda. This colorful cocktail is a flavorful representation of St. Croix’s lush produce.

21. Sunset Sip

Close-up view of a Sunset Sip cocktail with an orange gradient — A beautifully layered Sunset Sip cocktail representing the colors of a sunset.

Just like its name suggests, the Sunset Sip reflects the islands’ vibrant sunsets. This cocktail combines vodka, orange juice, and grenadine, creating a beautiful gradient that is as visually pleasing as it is delicious.

22. Virgin Islands Breeze

High angle view of a Virgin Islands Breeze cocktail with tropical colors — A refreshing Virgin Islands Breeze cocktail showcasing its vibrant hues.

The Virgin Islands Breeze features white rum, pineapple juice, and coconut water to bring a refreshing, smooth experience. Whether enjoyed at a local bar or on the beach, this drink perfectly encapsulates island life.

23. Cacao Cocktail

Eye-level view of a Cacao Cocktail with rich chocolate tones — A rich Cacao Cocktail featuring deep chocolate color and elegant presentation.

For dessert lovers, the Cacao Cocktail made with chocolate liqueur, rum, and cream is an indulgent option. It pairs beautifully with the relaxed atmosphere of the island, ensuring a sweet end to your evening.

24. Spicy Paloma

Close-up view of a Spicy Paloma cocktail with a chili salt rim — A Spicy Paloma cocktail with a zesty presentation, highlighting its unique flavors.

The Spicy Paloma mixes chili-infused tequila with grapefruit juice and soda, creating a drink that balances sweetness with heat. This cocktail appeals strongly to adventurous palates seeking something different.

25. Island Breeze

High angle view of an Island Breeze cocktail showcasing its layered colors — A refreshing Island Breeze cocktail with layers of tropical flavors.

Rounding out our selection, the Island Breeze showcases St. Croix’s ethos. Mixing local rum, pineapple juice, and cranberry juice, this drink is fruity, refreshing, and a true taste of the island.

Cheers to St. Croix’s Cocktail Culture

St. Croix is a treasure trove of cocktail experiences waiting to be discovered. Each drink tells a story, reflecting the island’s history, culture, and natural beauty. From a vibrant Rum Punch on the beach to a rich Mai Tai at a local bar, these cocktails offer an unforgettable taste of Caribbean spirit.

As you plan your visit, don’t miss these 25 exquisite cocktails. They promise to fill your days and nights with delightful flavors and memorable experiences. Here’s to new adventures and the beauty of St. Croix!

KW Adventure Explorer