Ultimate Guide to the Best Restaurants in St. John

St. John is a hidden gem in the Caribbean, renowned for its stunning beaches and lush landscapes. However, beyond its natural beauty lies a culinary scene that deserves the same recognition. From local delicacies to gourmet dining experiences, St. John’s restaurants offer a variety of flavors that reflect the culture and heritage of this picturesque island. In this blog post, we will explore 25 exceptional restaurants that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Each eatery provides something unique, making them worthy of a visit when you find yourself in this paradise.

Travel Guide: St John

1. The Fish Trap

A high angle view of the waterfront dining at The Fish Trap — Waterfront dining at The Fish Trap, St John

The Fish Trap is a beloved local eatery located in the heart of Cruz Bay. Known for its fresh seafood, this restaurant incorporates Caribbean and American flavors into its dishes. The ambience is casual yet inviting, perfect for families and couples alike. Don’t miss their famous grilled fish and spicy shrimp pasta!

Website: thefishtrapstjohn.com

2. ZoZo’s at the Sugar Mill

Eye-level view of ZoZo's stunning outdoor seating with floral decor — Outdoor seating area at ZoZo’s, with beautiful floral arrangements

ZoZo’s at the Sugar Mill offers an elegant dining experience with breathtaking views of the Caribbean Sea. The restaurant specializes in contemporary Italian cuisine with a local twist. Enjoy their signature homemade pastas and an extensive wine list while watching the sunset over the horizon.

Website: zozos.net

3. Ocean 362

Wide angle view of Ocean 362's beachfront dining area — Beachfront dining area at Ocean 362, offering stunning ocean views

Ocean 362 is perched on a hillside, providing panoramic views of the sea and sky. This restaurant prides itself on using fresh, local ingredients to create a menu that evolves with the seasons. Seafood is a highlight, particularly the catch of the day, made with innovative cooking techniques that enhance the natural flavors.

Website: ocean362.com

4. Morgan’s Mango

High angle view of a tropical-themed dining space at Morgan's Mango — Tropical decor and vibrant colors at Morgan’s Mango, setting a cheerful atmosphere

Morgan’s Mango is known for its lively atmosphere and vibrant Caribbean cuisine. With an extensive menu that caters to all tastes, this restaurant offers everything from fresh seafood to vegetarian options. Be sure to try their famous mango chutney and signature cocktails!

Website: morgansmango.com

5. The Longboard

Close-up view of a beautifully presented dish from The Longboard — Vibrant dish presentation at The Longboard, showcasing local flavors

The Longboard is a contemporary bistro known for its laid-back vibe and delicious food. Focusing on local, fresh ingredients, their menu features a mix of Caribbean and American classics with a modern twist. Their beachside location makes for a perfect dining experience after a day in the sun.

Website: thelongboardstjohn.com

6. La Tapa

Eye-level view of a beautifully arranged tapas platter at La Tapa — Delightful tapas platter showcasing an array of flavors at La Tapa

La Tapa is a favorite for those looking to indulge in a tapas-style meal. This cozy restaurant offers a diverse selection of small plates inspired by Mediterranean cuisine. The intimate setting is perfect for sharing dishes and enjoying a relaxed evening with friends.

Website: latapastjohn.com

7. Paradiso

High angle view of the al fresco dining area at Paradiso — Al fresco dining area at Paradiso, surrounded by lush greenery

Paradiso is known for its sophisticated dining experience, offering a menu that merges Italian and Caribbean cuisines. The setting is serene, surrounded by lush gardens, making it an ideal spot for special occasions. Their homemade pasta and fresh desserts are not to be missed.

Website: paradisostjohn.com

8. The Beach Bar

Wide angle view of the casual beachfront dining at The Beach Bar — Casual beachfront vibe at The Beach Bar, with guests enjoying the scenery

The Beach Bar offers a fun and relaxed dining atmosphere right on the sand. Known for its casual fare, the menu features burgers, sandwiches, and tropical drinks. It’s a great place to unwind after a day of exploring, as you listen to live music and soak in the sea breeze.

Website: stjohnbeachbar.com

9. Coral Bay Caribbean Oasis

Eye-level view of the vibrant exterior of Coral Bay Caribbean Oasis — Vibrant exterior of Coral Bay Caribbean Oasis, showcasing its colorful decor

Coral Bay Caribbean Oasis is an off-the-beaten-path gem that offers authentic Caribbean cuisine. With a menu filled with island favorites, this restaurant prides itself on its home-cooked meals and friendly service. Don’t forget to try the conch fritters and rum cocktails!

Website: coralbaycaribbean.com

10. Cruz Bay Landing

Wide angle view of the lively dining atmosphere at Cruz Bay Landing — Lively dining atmosphere at Cruz Bay Landing, filled with diners enjoying their meals

Cruz Bay Landing is a casual eatery that showcases the spirit of St. John through its local fare. The restaurant is popular for its burgers, seafood dishes, and refreshing cocktails. The friendly staff and laid-back atmosphere make it a must-visit.

Website: cruzbaylanding.com

11. The Terrace

High angle view of the elegantly set tables at The Terrace — Elegantly set dining tables at The Terrace, overlooking scenic views

The Terrace is known for its upscale dining experience and spectacular views. It offers a fine selection of gourmet Caribbean cuisine that is exquisitely prepared. The beautiful setting and impeccable service make this restaurant ideal for romantic dinners or special gatherings.

Website: theterracestjohn.com

12. Fish ‘N Lime Inn

Eye-level view of the cozy interior ambiance at Fish 'N Lime Inn — Cozy interior ambiance of Fish ‘N Lime Inn, inviting patrons to enjoy a meal

Fish ‘N Lime Inn is a charming spot that combines a rustic vibe with delicious food. This restaurant is famous for its hearty portions and friendly service. Featuring island-inspired dishes, their fish tacos and daily specials are popular among locals and visitors alike.

Website: fishnlime.com

13. Skinny Legs

Wide angle view of the relaxed outdoor seating at Skinny Legs — Laid-back outdoor seating area at Skinny Legs, inviting guests to enjoy a meal with a view

Skinny Legs is a beloved local hangout known for its casual atmosphere and fantastic burgers. Located in Coral Bay, this restaurant is perfect for a laid-back meal after a day at the beach. Guests rave about their famous fries and homemade pickles!

Website: skinnylegs.net

14. The Rum Hut

High angle view of colorful drinks and tropical decor at The Rum Hut — Colorful drinks served at The Rum Hut, surrounded by tropical decor

The Rum Hut offers a quintessential Caribbean experience with its open-air setting and vibrant atmosphere. Known for its extensive rum selection and creative cocktails, this place is perfect for unwinding after a day of adventure. Try their rum punch for a true taste of the island!

Website: rumhut.com

15. The Tap Room

Eye-level view of the inviting interior of The Tap Room — Inviting interior design of The Tap Room, ideal for casual dining

The Tap Room is an inviting craft beer restaurant that serves up a variety of delicious dishes made with local ingredients. The casual environment and extensive beer selection make it a great spot for both locals and tourists looking to relax and savor St. John’s unique flavors.

Website: taproomstjohn.com

16. Maho Crossroads

Wide angle view of the lively dining area at Maho Crossroads — Lively dining area at Maho Crossroads filled with guests enjoying their meals

Maho Crossroads is a casual dining spot that focuses on fresh, simple ingredients to create flavorful dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh salads, tacos, or seafood, this restaurant has something for everyone. The lively atmosphere and outdoor seating enhance the dining experience.

Website: maho.com

17. Love City Coffee

Eye-level view of a warm cup of coffee served at Love City Coffee — Warm cup of coffee served at Love City Coffee, perfect for a morning boost

Love City Coffee is the perfect place to start your day on the island. This charming cafe serves up delicious coffee, pastries, and breakfast options. A cozy spot for both locals and tourists, it’s a favorite for brunch meetings or a quiet morning after swimming at the beach.

Website: lovecitycoffee.com

18. Miss Lucy’s

High angle view of the outdoor porch dining at Miss Lucy's — Outdoor porch dining area at Miss Lucy’s, offering a relaxed atmosphere

Miss Lucy’s is set in a charming location overlooking the sea and offers a menu filled with traditional Caribbean dishes. With a focus on local ingredients, their jerk chicken and crab cakes are among the most popular items. The laid-back environment is perfect for enjoying a leisurely meal.

Website: misslucys.com

19. The Galleon

Wide angle view of the beautiful outdoor dining area at The Galleon — Outdoor dining area at The Galleon, with scenic views of the water

The Galleon offers an elegant dining experience with an extensive menu featuring fresh seafood and Caribbean flavors. The outdoor seating provides a picturesque setting to enjoy a meal while watching the sunset. Their meticulous preparation and presentation make every dish a feast for the eyes and palate.

Website: thegalleonstjohn.com

20. Noche

Eye-level view of Noche's colorful tapas dishes beautifully arranged — Beautifully arranged tapas dishes at Noche, showcasing vibrant ingredients

Noche is a unique restaurant that focuses on a variety of tapas, offering guests the opportunity to experience different flavors all in one meal. The eclectic menu reflects the diverse culinary influences of St. John, and the inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for sharing and mingling over food.

Website: noche.com

21. Cafe Roma

Close-up view of a delicious pizza served at Cafe Roma — Delicious pizza served at Cafe Roma, highlighting its fresh toppings

Cafe Roma offers an authentic taste of Italy in a warm and welcoming environment. Known for its thin-crust pizzas and homemade pasta, this is the perfect place for families and groups looking to enjoy a hearty meal. Their daily specials and fresh ingredients really shine through in every dish.

Website: caferoma.com

22. The Secret Garden

Eye-level view of the lush outdoor seating area at The Secret Garden — Lush outdoor seating area at The Secret Garden, surrounded by greenery

The Secret Garden is a hidden treasure that offers a menu brimming with local flavors and fresh ingredients. With an enchanting setting surrounded by gardens, this restaurant creates a magical ambiance for diners. Their creative dishes and exquisite presentation make every meal special.

Website: thesecretgarden.com

23. High Tide Bar & Grill

Wide angle view of the lively bar scene at High Tide Bar & Grill — Lively bar scene at High Tide Bar & Grill, inviting guests to enjoy drinks and bites

High Tide Bar & Grill is known for its fun, vibrant atmosphere and delicious bar fare. Guests can enjoy a selection of burgers, seafood, and refreshing cocktails while watching sports on large screens. The open-air seating allows for an enjoyable dining experience under the sun.

Website: hightide.com

24. Caramba!

Eye-level view of a colorful dish presented at Caramba! — Colorful dish presentation at Caramba!, showcasing its vibrant ingredients

Caramba! offers a unique blend of Caribbean and Latin cuisine, providing diners with a diverse menu. Known for its lively atmosphere, guests can indulge in a variety of flavorful dishes and refreshing drinks. The creative combinations and friendly service make this a must-visit spot.

Website: caramba.com

25. The Delly Deck

High angle view of the outdoor seating area at The Delly Deck — Outdoor seating area at The Delly Deck, ideal for casual dining

The Delly Deck is a fun, casual spot that welcomes guests with a relaxed atmosphere and great food. Featuring a mix of sandwiches, salads, and burgers, this restaurant is perfect for a quick bite or leisurely dining experience. Enjoy your meal while taking in the beautiful harbor views.

Website: dellydeck.com

Conclusion

St. John’s culinary scene is as diverse and vibrant as its landscapes. From waterfront dining to cozy cafes, each restaurant offers a unique experience that celebrates the flavors of the Caribbean. Whether you’re indulging in fresh seafood or savoring local specialties, you will surely find your favorite culinary spot amidst the 25 exceptional eateries listed above. So, the next time you visit St. John, make sure to explore these hidden gems and discover the unseen flavors of this enchanting island!